Wednesday, February 29, 2012
Nuclear Power: Yay or Nay?
With the debate over renewable energy intensifying with the presidential election rolling around the corner, questions of whether the US should increase their investment in nuclear energy have become increasingly highlighted in light of the nuclear disaster in Japan and Iran's plans to build a fully functional nuclear power plant. One of the major concerns against having nuclear power is the destructive aftermath of a meltdown, which was evident at Chernobyl and in Japan. However, the largest concern should be with criminals and terrorist organizations having access to nuclear material. Bubba the overweight private security guard at the front gate of such nuclear compounds does not inspire much confidence. On the other hand, activists fighting nuclear power plant construction need to come up with a choesive and coherent alternative in lieu of nuclear power. Fossil fuels will eventually run out and there are not enough solar panels around in Southern California, except on major military installations (i.e. 29 Palms and Camp Pendleton). Moreover, solar panels are expensive and are they really worth the return for a 3 person household? Energy efficient lightbulbs are good, but not everyone uses them. Hybrid cars are expensive at $30,000 for a Prius and Insight with all the fancy gadgets. Or you can buy a Chevy Volt and the battery will explode three days after you buy it, hence their recall a couple of months ago. If there is a comprehensive effort to resist nuclear power, those advocates need to outline their plan and come up with an equally financially-feasible alternative, especially in these economic times.
Sunday, February 26, 2012
Boycotts and other forms of protest
With fuel prices going past the $4 mark and into the $5 mark and higher as we head into the summer, the idea of boycotting gas has come up again. Here's the proposal: don't buy gas until the price goes back down. Here's the problem: in a car culture where a lot of people need to drive to get to work or for those who drive for a living, there seems to be little away to avoid buying that gas. Unless these individuals seeking to boycott gas can gather a large following ans sustain such a boycott over a period of one year or more, they will not succeed. In addition, how will they gather more supporters from a culture and environment where a lot of people have cars?
A lot of people associate the boycott with the civil rights movement, but it occurred as early as the American Revolution. However, most people don't think about the boycott prior to the 1950s, such as when African American women boycotted Harlem butchershops because the prices of meat were so high. These women banded together with other white women and protested as well, setting up human barricades in front of the butchershops. Eventually, the butchershops shut down for upwards of a week to force their 'producers' and the federal government to lower prices.
For those seeking to boycott gas in order to try and lower gas prices, they should take a lesson out from these Harlem women.
A lot of people associate the boycott with the civil rights movement, but it occurred as early as the American Revolution. However, most people don't think about the boycott prior to the 1950s, such as when African American women boycotted Harlem butchershops because the prices of meat were so high. These women banded together with other white women and protested as well, setting up human barricades in front of the butchershops. Eventually, the butchershops shut down for upwards of a week to force their 'producers' and the federal government to lower prices.
For those seeking to boycott gas in order to try and lower gas prices, they should take a lesson out from these Harlem women.
Sunday, February 19, 2012
Pacifism During War
Reading about pacifists during WWII was actually quite intriguing since WWII is remembered as the 'Good War' that seemed to garner public support as Americans on the home front scrapped together metal and endured food rationing to support the troops overseas. However, the reasoning that pacifists give for not supporting the war are flawed and their attempts to point out the hypocrisy of the US government magnifies the fact they are side-stepping the real reason for their pacifism. One argument that is really ridiculous is how they point out that the US did not conduct 'humane' warfare. Warfare is ugly and General Stonewall Jackson and Lee (CSA) made sure of it in order to bring about the total collapse and destruction of the enemy. Nowhere did these pacifists address the way Japanese forces tortured US prisoners (mutilating them and using them for bayonet practice are just a couple of examples) The US utilized the atomic bomb to coerce Japan into surrendering because the Japanese military would drag out the fight and the eventual conquest of Japan would cost the lives of hundreds of thousands of Marines, sailors, and soldiers. It is very convenient for a pacifist to make such an outlandish statement from the comfort of their own home while fellow Americans are getting shot at. It makes me wonder about conscientious objectors today in light of the recent Iraq conflict. Yes, the reasoning for entering Iraq was flawed because there were no weapons of mass destruction that Bush claimed there were. However, if Saddam was able to orchestrate the continuous murder of his own citizens and we were apathetic, how will we be remembered by history? If we are not part of the solution, we are definitely part of the problem. Apathy is a strong weapon.
Saturday, February 4, 2012
Antebellum Communitarian Movement: Good initiative, bad judgment...
John Noyes tries to create a community based on the Christians of the book of Acts who share all they have with one another willingly, engage in open confessions, and 'complex marriage.' Not surprisingly, Noye's vision of these communities were based on his own life experiences. From the very beginning, one can see a sense of trouble already brewing in this utopia. If complex marriage is allowed, won't there be tension in the community already when ex-husbands and ex-wives argue and fight each other? Looking at this community from a business perspective, if there is constant sharing, there is no viable incentive for a honest hard day's labor. Why should someone work hard and wind up having to share with another person who may be a slouch? The article also glosses over the opposition to Fourierism and the Oneida community by lumping them together into the clergy department: which clergyman provided the stiffest opposition and what did they do to hinder the community (aside from publicly condemn them)?
Flash forward to today: would such a movement thrive and flourish in this type of economy? I propose that it would not. Here are the reasons why not: greed and materialism (based on a 'me,me' world, individuals want what is best for themselves and are not always willing to sacrifice their portion of the pie for the common good). Tension from within a community left unresolved will almost inevitably lead to its downfall. Even though there may be some individuals who may thrive in such an environment, it would only be temporary.
Flash forward to today: would such a movement thrive and flourish in this type of economy? I propose that it would not. Here are the reasons why not: greed and materialism (based on a 'me,me' world, individuals want what is best for themselves and are not always willing to sacrifice their portion of the pie for the common good). Tension from within a community left unresolved will almost inevitably lead to its downfall. Even though there may be some individuals who may thrive in such an environment, it would only be temporary.
Friday, February 3, 2012
Social Movements: Occupy Wall Street
The Occupy Wall Street movement seems to be in its valley phase, going through some re-building, drawing more dedicated members, clarifying (hopefully) the major issues they want to tackle, and perhaps even looking at new tactics. Although the concerns they address (i.e. increasing tuition costs at public universities, bailout of large banks-B of A, Wells Fargo, Chase, etc.) are noble, their failure to coherently communicate and provide a solution are hurting their cause. If more regulations are placed on businesses, those businesses will either fight back vigorously with their team of top-notch lawyers or move elsewhere. If public schools do not receive enough funding from the state or federal government, or private donors, schools will have to make up that deficit somehow by raising fees or voraciously cutting services.
The Occupy Wall Street movement needs to efficiently utilize non-traditional methods of advocating for change. One way they failed to do so was when they occupied a portion of the LA City Hall and when they stood their ground in front of a farmers' market. These protestors hurt the very people they supposedly tried to aid: small business owners or entrepreneurs. Occupy Wall Street has branched out into many different cells, each operating on its own without direction from a central hub. Occupy Wall Street should form partnerships with organizations that share similar goals, gaining new members/supporters in the process and perhaps honing its tactics alongside those that work.
Moreover, the Occupy Wall Street and its subsequent off-shoots should develop a strategy to attain political office or at last have such an impact among politicians that its voice must be heard by politicians seeking re-election.
The Occupy Wall Street movement needs to efficiently utilize non-traditional methods of advocating for change. One way they failed to do so was when they occupied a portion of the LA City Hall and when they stood their ground in front of a farmers' market. These protestors hurt the very people they supposedly tried to aid: small business owners or entrepreneurs. Occupy Wall Street has branched out into many different cells, each operating on its own without direction from a central hub. Occupy Wall Street should form partnerships with organizations that share similar goals, gaining new members/supporters in the process and perhaps honing its tactics alongside those that work.
Moreover, the Occupy Wall Street and its subsequent off-shoots should develop a strategy to attain political office or at last have such an impact among politicians that its voice must be heard by politicians seeking re-election.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)