John Noyes tries to create a community based on the Christians of the book of Acts who share all they have with one another willingly, engage in open confessions, and 'complex marriage.' Not surprisingly, Noye's vision of these communities were based on his own life experiences. From the very beginning, one can see a sense of trouble already brewing in this utopia. If complex marriage is allowed, won't there be tension in the community already when ex-husbands and ex-wives argue and fight each other? Looking at this community from a business perspective, if there is constant sharing, there is no viable incentive for a honest hard day's labor. Why should someone work hard and wind up having to share with another person who may be a slouch? The article also glosses over the opposition to Fourierism and the Oneida community by lumping them together into the clergy department: which clergyman provided the stiffest opposition and what did they do to hinder the community (aside from publicly condemn them)?
Flash forward to today: would such a movement thrive and flourish in this type of economy? I propose that it would not. Here are the reasons why not: greed and materialism (based on a 'me,me' world, individuals want what is best for themselves and are not always willing to sacrifice their portion of the pie for the common good). Tension from within a community left unresolved will almost inevitably lead to its downfall. Even though there may be some individuals who may thrive in such an environment, it would only be temporary.
I agree that such a utopian vision probably wouldn't fly today because of materialism. I am particularly struck by the lack of sacrifice that most Americans have made for the past 2 wars. During WW II, people conserved, rationed things (like sugar and rubber), and grew gardens to provide for themselves.
ReplyDelete