Thursday, April 5, 2012

Native American Repatriation

The Native American Repatriation Movement is one that is often obscured by other more highly-visible social movements, but it is nonetheless an important part of California history, especially here in Southern California and at our own school. Native American tribes have argued that artifacts and human remains be returned to them out of respect for the fact that those items belonged to their ancestors and that the human remains should be buried in accordance with their respective cultures and traditions. Yet, scientists point out that these artifacts should be preserved with delicate care and not just be re-buried, forever lost. With delicate care, these artifacts can serve as a visual and physical symbol of their past for subsequent generations of other non-Native American groups to observe. This is an issue that will not be resolved anytime soon.

The Kennewick Man case presents a very interesting finding with serious ramifications. If this person was not Native American, then could the whole land bridge theory be discredited as a result? What if this person was just a wayward traveler or trader who did business with the Native Americans and was killed, body dumped somewhere, and eventually found its way into a river? This case also shows problems with repatriation: which tribe would be rewarded the remains if none of them could establish 'ownership'?

No comments:

Post a Comment